Monsters Don’t Always Wear Masks

Word Count: 1805

Read Time: 8 minutes

“Some stories are hard to tell. This is one of them.”

These words have echoed across the internet as news broke about the conviction of a once-beloved ex-family member. Headlines blazed, social feeds erupted, and a mugshot splashed across screens—another case of trust shattered, innocence destroyed. But behind every headline is a human story: someone left reeling, someone forever changed.

Introduction

I used to believe love was enough—that with enough faith, commitment, and hope, two people could weather any storm. I believed in happy endings, in redemption, in the transformative power of shared dreams. And for a while, it seemed like I was living the kind of love story you see in movies—swept off my feet by a man whose smile could light up a room, whose eyes promised new beginnings. But life has a way of shattering our illusions, sometimes in the most brutal ways possible. This isn’t just a story about heartbreak or betrayal. It’s about how the person you trust most can have secrets so dark, so unimaginable, that they fracture your sense of reality. It’s about grief, anger, confusion, and the long road to reclaiming your own truth. If you’ve ever wondered how someone could miss the signs, or if you’ve ever doubted what you knew about someone you loved, this is for you. Because sometimes, the monsters don’t wear masks, they look like the people we once called home.


The Beginning: Falling Under the Spell

A long time ago, I met the most beautiful man—or so I thought. He was tall, with striking green eyes that seemed to see right through you, and dark black curly hair that made him stand out in every crowd. I remember the first time I saw him, the way my breath caught in my throat, the flutter of hope that maybe, just maybe, this was the start of something real. I hadn’t planned on meeting anyone. In fact, I was a mess—heartbroken from a recent breakup, barely able to pick myself up off the floor. My best friend at the time, always looking out for me, decided to play matchmaker. She set me up with a former classmate of hers, promising that he was different, that he could make me smile again. And she was right. From that first blind date, sparks flew. It was effortless, intoxicating. We laughed until our sides hurt, finished each other’s sentences, and dreamed out loud about all the things we wanted from life. I felt seen, cherished, wanted in a way I hadn’t in years. The pain of my last relationship faded into the background. The world seemed full of possibility. It was a whirlwind. Eight months after that first date, we were married.


The Relationship: When Love Isn’t Enough

Our relationship started with the best of intentions. Nobody goes into marriage expecting to fail. We certainly didn’t. I wanted so desperately to be a wife, a mom, to build something solid and lasting after so much loss and instability in my life. We tried to have a baby. We shopped for houses with white picket fences, imagined holidays filled with laughter and love.


But reality wasn’t as picture-perfect as our dreams.

The world seemed determined to test us. At first, it was trivial arguments over the toilet seat, frustrations about who didn’t mop the kitchen. Silly, petty annoyances that all couples have, but for us, they started to pile up. The cracks began to show. And then they grew. The arguments became more frequent, sharper, more personal. Words turned into shouts, shouts turned into slammed doors, and then, one day, it became physical. I wish I could say I left at the first sign of violence, but the truth is, when you’re in it, you keep hoping things will get better. You blame stress, outside pressures, anything but the person in front of you. Our families didn’t help. His mother, bitter and closed-minded, hated me for my skin color. She saw me as a threat.  She never forgave me for being Black, convinced that her son’s happiness couldn’t possibly include me. Meanwhile, my own mother, terrified that I would end up alone, urged me not to give up. She told me to work it out, to keep trying, and not become another statistic from a broken home. But love alone wasn’t enough. The fights continued, the bruises—emotional and physical—lingered. And then came the final betrayal.


Infidelity: The Moment Everything Changed

I still remember the day I found the bracelet—a gold diamond tennis bracelet, beautiful but utterly foreign to me.

It was wedged under the car seat. Everyone who knows me knows I don’t wear gold. He’d never given it to me, never hinted at it. In that moment, the truth hit me like a punch to the gut. He was cheating. Maybe he was careless, maybe he wanted me to find it, but either way, the illusion shattered. I didn’t want to fail. I didn’t want to admit that I’d made a mistake, that love hadn’t been enough to save us. But a relationship can’t survive on the efforts of just one person. It takes two. Trust, once broken, is nearly impossible to rebuild. So I left.


“Do You Know This Person?”: The Day My Past Came Knocking

Years passed. Life moved on, as it always does. I rebuilt, slowly. From time to time, I’d get phone calls from private investigators looking for him. I didn’t think much of it—the last time I saw him was in the courthouse, divorce papers trembling in my hand. I figured he’d moved on, maybe found happiness with someone else. Then, one day, my phone started buzzing with text messages from unfamiliar numbers. Each one asked, “Do you know this person?” and included a link. At first, I ignored them. But the messages kept coming—one a day, then three, then seven in a single day. It felt like my number had leaked to a swarm of burner phones. I never clicked the links, but my curiosity got the better of me. I turned to social media, searching for his name. The last time I’d heard, he’d moved on with his side piece, had three children. But now, a different story emerged. There it was, in black and white—an article about his arrest and his court case. The link the anonymous phone number kept sending was to a report about his conviction and sentencing. Nine counts. Twenty-one years. I stared at the mugshot on my screen. The once-vibrant green eyes looked hollow, dead. The face I’d loved was gone, replaced by a shell of a man I didn’t recognize. My hands shook as I read the details—child molestation, abuse, the unimaginable made real.


Aftermath: Living With the Unthinkable

Listening to his sentencing, I felt a strange detachment, like I was watching someone else’s life unravel. Twenty-one years. He’ll be in his seventies if he ever gets out. Everyone knows what happens to people convicted of crimes like this in prison. But even then, I couldn’t muster any sympathy. He read a statement, written in advance apologizing for the pain he’d caused, appearing to cry—but no tears came. It was a performance, nothing more. I’d seen it before, in news coverage of infamous criminals—how they only show emotion when they got caught. It was empty, hollow.

His case reminded me of Susan Smith the mother who murdered her two sons, then lied about it, showing no emotion until her sentence was handed down. That’s what I saw in him: a man who thought he could talk his way out, who only showed regret when it was too late. And then there was the victim—a girl, only ten when he entered her life, suffering abuse for five years. My heart broke for her. I hope she finds the help she needs, that she learns she is not defined by what was done to her. I hope she finds peace, healing, and a future far brighter than the darkness she endured.


The Lingering Questions: Could I Have Known?

Even years later, I find myself haunted by questions.

Did he do this when we were together?

Did I miss something?

Were there other children, other victims, whose pain went unnoticed? I used to believe that when someone you love does something terrible, you should have known. There must have been signs, some deep intuition, some clue.

Nothing about our life together suggested he was hiding such darkness. Not in the bedroom, not in our conversations, not in the way he interacted with children. Between us, we had ten nieces and nephews. I never saw him act inappropriately. He never made me uncomfortable, never lingered too long, never joked about things that were inappropriate.

That’s the part that haunts me the most. If monsters always looked like monsters, it would be easy to protect ourselves and the ones we love. But sometimes, evil wears the face you once admired.

Sometimes, the people closest to us are the best at hiding their secrets. My best friend put it plainly, in the way only he can: “We don’t know what it’s like to be molesters, because we aren’t.” He’s right. There’s darkness in some people that we can’t fathom, can’t predict, can’t prepare for. Again, my thoughts go back to the young victim who was brave enough to say no more.


Conclusion: The Truth Behind the Green Eyes

This is not the story I ever wanted to tell.

And sometimes, telling the truth is the first step toward freedom. The man I loved is gone, replaced by the reality of what he is and what he’s done. I mourn not just the relationship, but the person I thought I knew. I grieve for his victims, for every life touched by his choices.


If you or someone you know is struggling in the aftermath of abuse or betrayal, please reach out for help. Healing begins with truth—and you are worthy of healing.

  • National Sexual Assault Hotline: 1-800-656-HOPE (4673)
  • Childhelp National Child Abuse Hotline: 1-800-4-A-CHILD (1-800-422-4453)

May those living with grief, confusion, or the aftermath of trauma find comfort, resilience, and hope. Your feelings are valid. Your path forward is yours alone, and you are deserving of healing and peace.

Discover more from Sunny Larue

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading